Monarch vs YNAB vs Sequence: Track It, Plan It or Move It?

Ari SchlachtContent Lead
SHARE

Monarch shows you where your money went. YNAB helps you decide where it should go before you spend it. Both are good at that. But when you run a business, there's a catch people don't say as much.

Neither one actually moves your money. Every dollar still sits in the same checking account, so the plan lives in the app and the money never follows it. The first bill that comes through takes whatever's there.

Let's say you run a salon. Square pays out $3,486.20 on a Tuesday, and in YNAB you give $612 of it to Taxes. Wednesday the color order goes out for $1,140.73. Thursday the rent pulls. By Friday the Taxes category is red, and Monarch shows you the same thing at the end of the month. And you're like, "Well, great, I'm broke."

Then the quarterly tax payment comes due, and that $612 already paid for foils. So it goes on a card, your own paycheck slides another week, and a busy month still feels short.

I've spoken to thousands of owners in this exact spot. Whatever cash flow software they already run, what fixes it is moving each dollar where it needs to go the moment it lands. So the real question is what moves the money underneath, and which app you keep on top of it.

Sequence moves each dollar as it lands

There are two ways to run your money. The first is to plan or track it while the dollars sit together in one account. The second is to give every job its own account and send the money there as it arrives. Monarch and YNAB are both the first kind. Sequence is the second.

The first way works fine for a household with one paycheck. A business is different. Deposits come in lumpy, and the same checking account holds the tax money, the supply budget, the rent and whatever's left for you. One owner told me why they didn't go with YNAB: with the budget separate from the bank, they had to be in it every day, because "in my checking account, I still have a giant chunk of money. It's also spendable."

Behind the scenes, you point your Square payouts at a feature called an income source instead of your checking account. An income source is an account inside Sequence with its own account and routing number, and it's where your plan starts. In Sequence, each move is an automation. You set it up with a rule that says when it runs, what it checks first and where the money goes.

Let's say the same $3,486.20 payout lands on Tuesday. Before you've opened anything, it's already split:

Account

What the automation does

Amount

Taxes

Sends 17.5% of every payout

$610.09

Supplies

Tops up to $2,000, then stops

$737.82

Rent

Sends a fixed $400 every payout

$400.00

Owner Pay

Sends 15% of every payout

$522.93

Profit

Sends 5% of every payout

$174.31

Checking

What's left, to spend

$1,041.05

I made those numbers up, and your accountant gives you the real tax percentage. Don't do the math. The point is that every job got paid before anything else could reach it.

The tax money stays put. It lands in its own account the moment Square pays you. The color order on Wednesday comes out of Supplies, so it never touches Taxes. When the quarterly payment comes due, the money is sitting there.

Supplies has a ceiling. This is the part I like most. Instead of finding out at month end that supplies ran over, you decide up front: the Supplies account tops up to $2,000 and stops there. You pay the supply house from that account's debit card. If it runs low before the next payout, you know it's an ordering problem before it's a cash problem.

You get paid on a schedule. Owner Pay fills from every payout, busy week or slow week. A scheduled automation then pays you the same amount every other Friday into your personal checking.

The card and the household bills get covered. The same plan can pay your business card's statement balance on the 20th and move money to the account your mortgage pulls from. Business money and household money sit on one plan, each in its own place.

There's nothing to recategorize. In YNAB you'd be moving dollars between categories every time a payout lands. Here the automations do the moving, and you check in when you want to.

Now, you might be thinking you could open five accounts at your own bank and move the money yourself. You can, and plenty of owners try it. It holds until a busy week or a vacation, when nobody sits down to do the transfers, and everything piles back into checking. The automations are what keep it going when you're not watching.

On timing: moves between your Sequence accounts happen instantly. Money pulled in from another bank takes 2 to 3 business days, which is why I point Square straight at the income source. The money starts its trip already inside the plan.

And you can keep the app you like. Each Sequence account is a real account, so you can add it to Monarch or YNAB next to your other accounts. Owners do exactly this. One runs a company alongside a nonprofit foundation, and uses Sequence for how the money gets to each place, then Monarch to check it got there. Another owns two companies, one of them holding a rental property, and added their Sequence accounts to YNAB so they could keep tracking expenses there. They told me that's what let them use Sequence to the fullest.

If your salon also has booth renters or a partner, my salon setup post walks through those accounts.

Monarch tracks every account in one view

If you've lost track of where the money went last month, Monarch is built for that.

What Monarch does well

Monarch connects your bank accounts, cards, loans, real estate and investments in one place. It categorizes your transactions, tracks budgets and goals, shows your net worth and keeps an eye on your subscriptions. You can invite your partner or your advisor into the same view at no extra cost. Its Plus plan adds forecasting and lets you track multiple income sources like a small business. If you want the whole picture, business and household together, it's a strong pick.

Where Monarch stops short for a business

Monarch's site describes connecting, categorizing and reporting on your accounts. It doesn't describe moving money between them. For most owners that's the gap. Once you have a lease, a supply house and quarterly taxes, knowing where the money went matters less than having it in the right place before the bills arrive.

In the salon, the payout lands in checking. The color order and the rent come out of the same balance. At month end, Monarch's report shows supplies ran over and the tax money got spent. Everything it shows you is accurate, and all of it arrives after the money's gone.

YNAB plans every dollar before you spend it

If you've ever spent money you'd already promised to something else, YNAB is built for that.

What YNAB does well

YNAB is a method as much as an app. You give every dollar a job before you spend it, and you plan with only the money you actually have. You can share a subscription with up to five people and create separate plans, including one for a small business. It also runs live sessions and keeps a directory of YNAB coaches. If you want to think hard about every dollar, YNAB will teach you to.

Where YNAB stops short for a business

YNAB's categories are a plan for the money already sitting in your accounts. The dollars stay where they are, which for a lot of owners means one business checking account. So a card swipe on Wednesday takes whatever's there, whatever category you meant it for, and you find out when the category goes red.

For a business that means a lot of upkeep. Every payout is a different size, so every week you sit down, assign the new money and move dollars between categories when something runs over. A flute repair shop owner who used YNAB as an envelope system for their business, saving month by month for annual bills, told me it's "a lot of manual effort every time you have to go in there and recategorize things and juggle money."

A spa owner we work with hit the same wall. He found traditional budgeting tools too manual, so he ran Profit First in spreadsheets, and when the invoices for a big buildout ran past his operating budget, he dipped into the tax money. On Sequence, every deposit now splits into its own accounts as it lands, and he went from no cushion to a multi-month reserve in six months.

The envelopes are a great idea, and they hold up best as real accounts. That's the same idea behind Profit First, and in Sequence each envelope is one.

Which one fits your business: Monarch, YNAB and Sequence side by side

Each tool does a different job: Monarch tracks the money, YNAB plans it and Sequence moves it.


Monarch

YNAB

Sequence

Main job

Tracks every account in one view

Plans every dollar before you spend it

Moves each dollar as it lands

Best for

Seeing business, household and investments together

Owners who'll assign every dollar each week

Owners whose money has to cover taxes, supplies, rent and their own pay

Where the money sits

In the accounts it landed in

In your existing accounts, split into categories

In separate accounts, one per job

How the budget holds

You review spending in reports

You stick to the plan and recategorize

The money is already in its account

Business use

Plus tracks multiple income sources

A separate small-business plan

Business and household money on one plan

With the other two

Shows your Sequence accounts

Tracks your Sequence accounts

Runs underneath either app

Pick by what you need most:

  • Keep Monarch if you want to see everything in one place, including the household and your investments.

  • Keep YNAB if you like giving every dollar a job and you'll sit down with it every week.

  • Put Sequence underneath either one if you need the money in the right account before anything can spend it.


Some owners love YNAB's categories, and that's a matter of preference. One owner who ran their money that way told me they could still overspend whenever they wanted, and it didn't make any difference. Putting the money in its own account first is what Sequence adds.

Where to start: one automation under the app you keep

Keep whichever app you like. Then:

  1. Open a Sequence income source and point your payouts at it.

  2. Add one automation that sends a share of every payout to a Taxes account. Your accountant gives you the percentage.

  3. Watch a payout or two come through.

  4. Add Supplies and Owner Pay next.

You can change any automation whenever you want. If you'd like a hand mapping your salon's accounts, book a call with my team and we'll build the first version with you.

FAQ

Is Monarch or YNAB better for a small business?

Monarch is better for seeing all your accounts, business and household, in one place. YNAB is better for planning every dollar before you spend it. Neither one describes moving money between accounts on its site, so you can pair the app you like with Sequence, which moves each payment into accounts for taxes, supplies, rent and your pay as it lands.

Can YNAB be used for a business?

Yes. YNAB lets you create a separate plan for a small business under the same subscription. The categories in that plan still describe money sitting in your existing accounts, so the plan holds as long as you keep assigning and recategorizing every week.

Does Monarch work for self-employed people?

Monarch's Plus plan lets you track multiple income sources like a small business, along with forecasting. It tracks the money. Moving each payment into separate accounts for taxes or your own pay is a different job, and that's the one Sequence does.

Do Monarch or YNAB move money between accounts?

Neither company's site describes moving money between accounts. Monarch connects and reports on your accounts, and YNAB helps you plan the money already in them. Sequence moves it, using automations you set up.

Can I use Sequence with Monarch or YNAB?

Yes. Each Sequence account is a real account, so you can connect it to Monarch or YNAB next to your other accounts. Owners run Sequence as the backend that moves the money and keep Monarch or YNAB as the dashboard.

What's the difference between budgeting and automating your money?

A budget is a plan for where money should go. Automating your money means it actually goes there: each payment is split into separate accounts the moment it lands, before a card swipe or a bill can spend it.